Maple Syrup Substitutes: Our Sweetest Alternatives (2024)

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Are you weary of the high cost of real maple syrup or simply want a healthier alternative? Whether it’s for health reasons, dietary restrictions, or you’ve just run out of your favorite sweetener, finding a good maple syrup replacement can be a game-changer. We’ve curated a list of the best substitutes for maple syrup that not only match the sweetness but also mimic the unique taste and consistency of the real thing.

Agave Nectar: A Natural Sweetener

Agave nectar, derived from the agave plant, is a popular maple syrup replacement. It has a similar consistency and a slightly different flavor, with a lower glycemic index. Agave nectar is a great substitute in recipes that call for maple syrup, especially in salad dressings and granola bars. Remember, because it’s sweeter, you’ll need smaller amounts than maple syrup.

You might consider it for something like Maple Cinnamon Butter.

Simple Syrup: A Less Expensive Alternative

Simple syrup, made by dissolving equal parts of sugar in water, is a less expensive alternative to maple syrup. Although it lacks the depth of flavor of real maple syrup, its neutral taste can be a plus in some recipes. It’s a good substitute in recipes where the flavor of maple syrup is not crucial. Its liquid form and sweetness make it a versatile maple syrup alternative.

Brown Rice Syrup: A Healthier Alternative

Brown rice syrup, made from fermented and cooked rice, is a healthier alternative to maple syrup. It has a complex flavor profile, with caramel notes and a nutty flavor. Although it’s not as sweet as maple syrup, it’s a great alternative in savory dishes and a good swap for a cup of sugar in baking recipes.

Honey: A Natural, Robust Flavor

Honey’s natural sweetness and robust flavor make it a great maple syrup substitute. Its rich flavor makes it a good substitute in recipes that call for a cup of maple syrup. However, it’s important to adjust your recipe as honey is sweeter and can affect the moisture content of your dish. It’s best to use it at room temperature to maintain the consistency of maple syrup.

For example, you could convert this recipe to Honey Cream Fudge.

Golden Syrup: Made from Sugar Beets or Sugar Cane

Golden syrup, made from sugar beets or sugar cane, is another great substitute for maple syrup. It has a color and consistency similar to light corn syrup but with a flavor closer to that of light molasses. It’s a great alternative in recipes where a maple flavor isn’t essential. While it’s not a common ingredient in North America, it’s widely available in grocery stores in the UK.

Coconut Nectar: A Unique Maple Syrup Alternative

Coconut nectar is a thick syrup extracted from the sap of coconut palms. It has a unique taste, slightly different from maple syrup, yet delicious. It’s a good substitute in recipes that call for a cup of molasses or honey. It’s also an excellent addition to barbecue sauce and salad dressings. Plus, it has health benefits, being rich in vitamins and amino acids.

Dark Corn Syrup: A Great Maple Syrup Substitute

Dark corn syrup, made from cornstarch and molasses, is a great substitute in baking recipes calling for maple syrup. It has a rich flavor, similar to that of dark molasses, and can provide the same sweetness and moisture to your baked goods. However, it might not be the healthiest substitute due to its high sugar content.

Dark corn syrup would work for this Maple Cinnamon Glaze.

Conclusion: Finding the Best Maple Syrup Replacement

Finding the best maple syrup substitute is all about understanding your needs and preferences. Whether you’re looking for a less expensive alternative, a healthier option, or simply a different flavor profile, there are plenty of options out there. So next time your recipe calls for a cup of maple syrup, don’t panic! Just reach for one of these great alternatives and continue cooking your favorite recipes.

Before you go, have a look at all of
our RECOMMENDED SUBSTITUTIONS!